top of page

Insurance Companies

Our agency’s continued legacy is to make integrity our priority.
Because of this we are currently partnered with some of the most reputable insurance companies in the industry.

Personal Insurance Companies

Callicoon Logo_edited_edited_edited_edit

Callicoon Co-Op Insurance
Jefferson, NY

Dryden Mutual Insurance Company Logo

Dryden Mutual Insurance
Dryden, NY

Eastern Mutual Insurance Logo

Eastern Mutual Insurance
Greenville, NY

Erie and Niagara Insurance Logo

Erie and Niagara Insurance
Williamsville, NY

Foremost Insurance Group

Foremost Insurance Group
Caledonia, MI

Nat Gen.png

National General

Winston-Salem, NC

Nationwide Insurance Logo

Nationwide Insurance
Columbus, OH

NYCM_edited_edited.png

NYCM Insurance
Edmeston, NY

Plymouth Rock Insurance Logo

Plymouth Rock
Boston, MA

Preferred Mutual Insurance Logo

Preferred Mutual Insurance
New Berlin, NY

Progressive_edited_edited.png

Progressive Insurance
Mayfield Village, OH

Otsego Mutual Insurance Logo

Otsego Mutual
Burlington Flats, NY

RT Specialties/Lovullo Logo

R-T Specialties/Lovullo
Depew, NY

Selective.png

Selective Flood
Philadelphia, PA

Travelers.png

Travelers Insurance

Hartford, CT

UNIG_edited_edited.png

Utica National

New Hartford, NY

Vermont Mutual.png

Vermont Mutual

Montpelier, VT

Commercial Insurance Companies

Acadia Insurance

Westbrook, ME

Acadia Insurance Logo

AmTrust
New York, NY

AmTrust Insurance Logo

Callicoon Co-Op Insurance
Jefferson, NY

Callicoon Logo.png

Chubb
Warren, NY

Chubb Insurance Logo

Cincinnati Insurance Companies
Fairfield, OH

Cincinnati_edited.png

Dryden Mutual Insurance
Dryden, NY

Dryden Mutual Insurance Logo

Eastern Mutual Insurance
Greenville, NY

Eastern Mutual Insurance Logo

Employers
Phoenix, AZ

Employers Insurance Logo

Erie and Niagara Insurance
Williamsville, NY

Erie and Niagara Insurance

Lodestar Claims & Risk Services
Blue Bell, PA

Lodestar Topaz Gigapixel 2x scale.png

Memic
Portland, ME

Memic Insurance Logo

Merchants Insurance Group
Buffalo, NY

Merchants Insurance Group

Nationwide Insurance
Columbus, OH

Nationwide Insurance Logo

New York State Insurance Fund
Albany, NY

New York State Insurance Fund Logo

NYMIR
Uniondale, NY

New-York-Municipal-Insurance-Reciprocal

NYSIR
Uniondale, NY

New York Schools Insurance Reciprocal Logo

NYCM Insurance
Edmeston, NY

NYCM_edited_edited.png

Philadelphia Insurance Co.
Bala Cynwyd, PA

Philadelphia Insurance Companies Logo

Preferred Mutual
New Berlin, NY

Preferred Mutual Insurance Logo

Progressive Insurance
Mayfield, OH

Progressive_edited_edited.png

RLI
Peoria, IL

RLI_edited.png

Selective Insurance Group
Branchville, NJ

Selective Insurance Group Logo

ShelterPoint Life Insurance 
Great Neck, NY

Shelter Point Life Insurance Company

Standard Security Life Insurance 

New York, NY

Standard Security Sq_edited_edited.png

The Hartford Insurance
Hartford, CT

The Hartford Insurance Logo

Travelers Insurance
Hartford, CT

Travelers Insurance Logo

Utica National
New Hartford, NY

UNIG_edited.jpg

Vermont Mutual
Montpelier, VT

Vermont Mutual Insurance Logo
Northern Insuring Agency, Inc. Logo

Plattsburgh

171 Margaret St.

Plattsburgh, NY 12901
Ph: 518-561-7000

Fax: 800-753-4530

Potsdam

69 Market St.

Potsdam, NY 13676
Ph: 315-769-2404

Fax: 800-753-4530

Glens Falls

21 Bay St.

Glens Falls, NY 12801
Ph: 518-499-0444

Fax: 800-753-4530

Hours of Operation:

Monday - Thursday: 8am - 4:30pm

Friday: 8am - 12pm

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram

Thanks for subscribing!

©2025 NORTHERN INSURING AGENCY, INC.

SITE DESIGNED BY 

Twenty-Six & Co., the creative agency responsible for the design of the Northern Insuring website.

Disclaimer: There is no guarantee insurance will be obtained, and any omissions or misstatements in the process of obtaining coverage can result in a declination of coverage

bottom of page